Elsa Dutton outfits start with prairie dresses, worn brown boots and practical layers. My Joshua Tree kitchen photo below brings in the wood beams, pale walls and warm browns I would borrow for a modern western outfit. Start with brown leather cowgirl boots for the clearest Western line, or saddle suede western boots for a more dressed-up version. For a lighter modern take, add a prairie rose mini dress or a wool utility bomber jacket.
Photo credit: Shopping and Info
Elsa Dutton’s wardrobe in 1883 pairs prairie dresses, ranch coats, brown lace-up boots. These are modern pieces for that Western-inspired look, not verified screen-worn items. Start with one layer or accessory and keep the rest of the outfit simple.
Some links in this post are affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Shop Elsa Dutton outfits now
Shop here
Photo credit: Tecovas
Shop here
Photo credit: Khaite
Elsa Dutton Outfits: Brown Western Boots First
Brown Leather Cowgirl Boots: Tecovas The Jamie
The round-toe brown cowgirl boots are the first pair I would consider for the modern outfit. The Jamie in Scotch goat leather has an 11-inch shaft, eight-row stitching and a stacked leather heel. Wear the tall shape with a prairie dress or tuck in straight jeans so the stitching shows. It is a modern choice, not a verified pair from Elsa’s wardrobe.
The Jamie product family has 4.83 out of 5 from 568 reviews. Shop here
Saddle Suede Western Boots: Khaite Nevada
The saddle suede western boots take the same idea in a dressier direction. The Nevada’s squared toe, shaped heel and tonal wingtip stitching give a plain dress a Western line; the side zipper keeps the shaft smooth. I would choose this pair for dinner rather than a trail outfit. Keep the rest simple so the suede and stitching can stand out. Shop here
Elsa Dutton’s 1883 costumes: what Janie Bryant designed
Costume designer Janie Bryant has said she built four main looks for Elsa, designed to change as her journey unfolded. The floral dress, blue polonaise outfit and Comanche vest were costume designs, not evidence that the modern brands below were worn on screen. These pieces borrow colors, fabrics and western details without claiming a screen match.
The White Floral Dress: Custom Costume, Similar Prairie Shapes
Elsa wore a white-and-blue floral dress designed by Janie Bryant. The cream flutter-sleeve prairie dress has a different neckline, sleeve and fabric detail. It is a modern alternative, not the original costume. Shop here
The Trail Trousers and Custom Comanche Vest
Bryant also describes Elsa trading a bracelet charm for trousers, then wearing a custom Comanche vest and fringed leggings made with cultural consultants. Those are specific costume designs, not the retail trench below. For an everyday practical layer instead, the dark-tan suede trench works over a plain blouse and jeans without pretending to reproduce the beaded costume. Shop here
The Blue Dress and Long Polonaise Jacket
Bryant describes Elsa starting the journey in a slim blue dress with a long polonaise jacket, shortened as the story progresses. The blue lace-trim blouse borrows the soft blue palette; the saddle-brown field coat gives you a durable outer layer. Neither is a replica or a screen-worn piece. Shop here
Costume look or everyday outfit: which should you buy?
For the costume look: start with the cream flutter-sleeve prairie dress for the white floral dress, or the blue lace-trim blouse with the saddle-brown field coat for the blue dress and long jacket. They borrow the colors and shapes, not the original costumes.
For everyday wear: the brown cowgirl boots with chocolate coated bootcut jeans are the easiest outfit to wear again and again. Add the dark-tan suede trench over a plain blouse when it gets cold.
If you buy one thing: choose the boots. They work with a prairie dress or with jeans, so they fit both ways of wearing the look.
Elsa Dutton Outfits: The Boots
Ariat Square-Toe Western Boots in Naturally Rich
The brown square-toe Western boots from Ariat have an embroidered shaft, an eleven-inch height and a low horseman heel. The square toe is a different shape from the lace-up and pointed-toe options already here. Wear them with the coated bootcut jeans or a simple prairie dress. Shop here
Dark-Brown Lace-Up Boots: Frye Sabrina 6G
Frye’s Sabrina offers dark-brown lace-up boots in dark brown leather, with a lugged sole and laces to the ankle. I would use it to give a soft dress more weight, rather than treat it as a verified show boot. Shop here.
Dolce Vita Klyde Boots: A Modern Western Alternative
The tall riding boot originally selected here is sold out. These cognac suede ankle boots are a different, modern western choice, with a pointed toe and block heel. I would wear the shorter shaft with the coated bootcut jeans. They are not a boot worn on the show. Shop here.
Elsa Dutton Outfits: The Prairie Dresses
DOEN Daphne Dress in Blanc Prairie Rose: A Prairie-Inspired Mini
The prairie rose mini dress is made from organic-cotton voile with an A-line shape, short puffed sleeves, lace trim and a pale-blue tie at the neckline. It is a prairie-inspired mini, not the dress worn on the show. Wear it with the brown boots above for a modern Western outfit. Shop here.
Christy Dawn Griselda Dress: The Floral Prairie Dress
Griselda in Wild Berries is a smocked floral prairie dress in cotton, with ruffled shoulder straps, a smocked bodice and contrast red piping on the tiered skirt. The color and construction are different from the screen costume. I would keep the coat and boots plain. Shop here.
Cleobella Indira Ankle Dress in Buttercream
The cream ankle dress has flutter sleeves, a softly gathered neckline and a defined waist. Wear it with the brown lace-up boots and barn coat for a prairie-inspired outfit rather than a screen replica. Shop here For the current style and sizing, browse the cream flutter-sleeve prairie dress.
Christy Dawn Renata Dress: The Button-Front Prairie Dress
Renata in Pine Foliage is a three-quarter-sleeve floral dress with a button-front bodice, a softly gathered V-neck and relaxed three-quarter sleeves. I would use the olive floral print with brown boots rather than another patterned piece. It is a modern choice, not Elsa’s custom costume. Shop here.
Cleobella Jewel Ankle Dress in Eglantine
The navy floral ankle dress gives the edit a darker option, with puffed sleeves and a shaped waist. The print is the statement, so keep the bandana for a different outfit. Shop here For the current style and sizing, browse the navy floral ankle dress.
L.L.Bean Mountain Classic Down Vest: The Layer for Cold Mornings
A cream cropped down vest is a modern layer for a cool desert morning, not a period piece from the show. L.L.Bean calls this light beige shade Shore. I would wear the short quilted shape with the bootcut jeans and a plain blouse instead of adding another long layer. Shop here.
Pink Printed Midi Dress for a Softer Western Outfit
The Jamie midi dress in Oree brings a pink-and-red print, slim straps and a button-front bodice. Add the barn coat on a cool evening; the brown boots keep it from feeling too delicate. Shop here For the current style and sizing, browse the pink printed midi dress.
For the boot part of a Western outfit, see the chic boots for fall travel and the western boots to wear with dresses and jeans.
Elsa Dutton Outfits: Western Accessories to Wear Now
Mocha Nubuck Belt with a Silver Buckle
B-low The Belt’s mocha nubuck Western belt has a broad silver buckle and tonal stitching. Wear it at the hip over the simple blouse and jeans, or use it to give a loose dress more shape. Measure for the hip fit rather than assuming your usual waist-belt size. Shop here
Cherrywood Shoulder Bag for a Modern Western Outfit
The deep oxblood pebbled leather shoulder bag from Hammitt has brown-red undertones and brushed gold hardware. A short strap makes it a shoulder bag; the longer removable strap gives you a crossbody option. It is a modern addition for carrying everyday things, not a period costume accessory. Shop here
Mixed-Metal Double Huggie Earrings
Small mixed-metal double huggie earrings from gorjana keep the neckline quiet next to the bandana. The joined gold-and-silver shape is useful if you mix the silver belt buckle with the bag’s gold hardware. Choose these for a simple modern finishing detail rather than a screen match. Shop here
Photo credit: Golden Goose
Elsa Dutton Outfits: The Coats and Layers
Madewell Utility Bomber Jacket in Shadow Melange: A Modern Layer
This wool-blend bomber jacket has a removable collar, drop shoulders and utility seaming, in a 60% wool and 40% recycled polyester blend. It is a modern layer, not a period replica. Wear it over a dress with the brown boots on a cooler day. Shop here.
Tobacco waxed suede fringe jacket: Golden Goose
Tobacco suede fringe jacket: Golden Goose is the designer piece I would use to bring the western mood into a modern wardrobe. Waxed cow suede, front patch pockets and fringe across the chest give it more weight than a light cotton layer. I would wear it with the chocolate jeans and a plain shirt, leaving the bandana off. This is a current designer choice, not Elsa’s custom Comanche vest or a verified screen-worn jacket. Shop here.
Lightweight Field Coat: A Similar Ranch Layer
A lightweight field coat from L.L.Bean gives this edit a similar ranch layer in saddle brown. The unlined cotton coat is a lighter option, with large front pockets and a contrasting collar. It is inspired by the practical side of the wardrobe, not a screen-worn coat. Shop here
Favorite Daughter Suede Charles Trench: The Long Trail Coat
For a longer layer with the same prairie utility, a dark-tan suede trench coat has the belted waist, storm flap and easy drape that make it feel like a modern nod to Elsa’s travel wardrobe. It is a similar style, not a piece worn on the show. Shop here.
Chocolate Coated Bootcut Jeans for a Modern Trail Outfit
L’AGENCE’s chocolate coated bootcut jeans offer a slim shape through the hip and knee with a small flare for boots. They are coated denim, not leather. Wear them with the dusty-blue blouse and mocha belt. Shop here
Photo credit: L.L.Bean
Elsa Dutton Outfits: The Bandana and Blouse
Cleobella Theodora Top: The Prairie Blouse
Puffed sleeves, lace trim and a soft dusty blue – the Theodora top is the prairie blouse without the costume feel. Tuck it into denim or wear it under the suede trench. Shop here.
More Character Style Edits
For another take on western dressing, browse Beth Dutton outfits and Monica Dutton outfits.
More Style Guides
- Beth Dutton Coats and Boots: Originals and Similar Styles
- What to Wear in Aspen in Fall: Hiking, Dinner and Town Outfits
- Long Wool Coats for Women: Tailored Shapes to Wear With Boots
Shop the Post: Elsa Dutton Outfits
- Tecovas The Jamie in Scotch Goat: round-toe brown cowgirl boots – Shop here
- Khaite Nevada Stretch High Boot in Saddle Suede: saddle suede western boots – Shop here
- DOEN Daphne Dress in Blanc Prairie Rose: prairie rose mini dress – Shop here
- Madewell Utility Bomber Jacket in Shadow Melange: wool-blend bomber jacket – Shop here
- cognac suede ankle boots
- mocha nubuck western belt
- cherrywood leather shoulder bag
- mixed-metal double huggie earrings
- cream flutter-sleeve prairie dress
- saddle-brown field coat
- chocolate coated bootcut jeans
- dusty-blue lace-trim blouse
- brown square-toe western boots
- dark-tan suede trench coat
- dark-brown lace-up boots
- navy floral ankle dress
- smocked floral prairie dress
- cream cropped down vest
- pink printed midi dress
- tobacco suede fringe jacket
- three-quarter-sleeve floral dress
